Thursday, August 20, 2009

The Economist - Health reform

http://www.economist.com/displaystory.cfm?story_id=14258740&fsrc=nwl

"...new poll conducted for The Economist by YouGov confirms that scepticism over the reform effort is widespread. Of those respondents expressing a clear view, twice as many believe reform on the scale Mr Obama is still contemplating will leave them worse off than today (38%) as believe they will be better off (19%). Over half are convinced they will end up paying more. And more people (59%) believe that any new system will lead to rationing of care than think it will lead to long-term cost savings (only 46%). Details are available at www.economist.com/yougovpoll..."

"...Jon Kingsdale. As head of the Commonwealth Connector, the official insurance exchange set up in Massachusetts...pioneering reformers in Europe and in Massachusetts have shown that universal coverage is achievable without a government-run insurer. Among the policies needed are strong regulation of insurers to prevent bad behaviour, subsidies for the poor and the creation of health-insurance exchanges..."

"...officially appointed committee of experts has just recommended that his state scrap the fee-for-service model of reimbursement, which many economists believe is at the heart of America’s health-inflation problem. Doing so would require his state to get a special waiver from the federal government, but this radical and hugely worthwhile proposal is now being seriously considered. Sadly, the idea is nowhere to be found in the leading bills in Washington, DC.

Mr Kingsdale does acknowledge that it is easier to pull off reform in a small and wealthy state like his than it would be at the national level, and accepts that his state has not yet actually passed any legislation that would curb health inflation. And given Congress’s history of fiscal irresponsibility, it is surely right to be sceptical about any strategy that expands entitlements today in the hope of forcing a fiscal crisis to win support for cost cuts tomorrow.

Mr Kingsdale sums it up this way: “Trying to anticipate and address related cost, quality and access issues in one national reform would be more than Herculean—it would be Sisyphean…Herculean effort, followed by failure, then a renewed attempt at reform, ad infinitum.” ..."

No comments:

Post a Comment